← All essays
Working Theory
No. 18
Author
Chelsea Stewart
Reading
2 min

Saying What You Mean in a Review

It needs to pop. It feels off. Make it cleaner. On the vague words teams use in design critique, what they cover up, and how to name the element and the effect instead.

Design review in context
Design review in context

I wrote about the word taste and how little it explains. Since then I have been paying attention to the rest of the vocabulary in design reviews, and taste is not alone. Most of the words we use to judge work are doing the same job. They let someone have an opinion without having to defend it.

Listen to a crit for ten minutes and you will hear them. It needs to pop. It feels off. Make it cleaner. It’s not quite there. Can we elevate it. Every one of those is a real reaction. None of them tells the person who made the work what to change.

mi-ji · App screens, end to end
mi-ji · App screens, end to end

What the vague words cost

When feedback is vague, the designer has to guess. They make a change, bring it back, and hear that it is still not quite there. Two or three rounds later someone finally says what they meant, which was that the headline is too small, or the blue looks like a competitor’s, or the page makes the company seem younger than it is. All of that was knowable in the first meeting.

The bigger cost is that vague language hides vague thinking. If I cannot say why something is wrong, there is a good chance I do not know yet. Forcing the sentence out is how I find out whether my reaction is about the work or about my mood that afternoon.

Monogram seal
Monogram seal

What I try to say instead

I try to name the element and the effect. The type is set too light for the size, so the headline reads as a caption. The illustration is warmer than everything around it, so it looks borrowed from another brand. The page asks for a decision before it has explained anything. Each of those points at something specific and says what it is doing to the person looking at it. The designer can disagree with me, which is fine. At least we are arguing about the same thing.

I hold my own team to this and I ask clients for it too. When a founder says it feels off, I ask what they were expecting to feel. Usually they know. They just were not asked.

Tailjoy · Supplement packaging system
Tailjoy · Supplement packaging system

Machines can’t read the room

This matters more now that a lot of feedback goes to tools as well as people. A model cannot read the room. If I tell it to make something pop, it will make something louder, and that is almost never what I meant. Precise language was always better for people. With machines it is the only kind that works.

Previous essay · No. 17The Median Is Free NowAnyone can get a decent logo, a decent landing page, or a decent paragraph in about thirty seconds. I am more interested in what that did to the word decent.

Have a project in mind?

Let’s design your next brand, product, website, launch or space.

Start a project inquiry
Start with